Bay Island is a neighborhood in South Pasadena, Florida. The majority of homes in this community are florida or contemporary style attached homes. They were built between 1971 and 1980. These homes offer 0 to 3 bedrooms and 1 bath to 3 bathrooms. Residences range in size from 555 to 2603 square feet in living space. Prices of homes for sale in Bay Island currently range from $119,000 to $269,000.
Min Price
Max Price
All Beds
All Baths
All Sizes
  • photos
  • list

near Bay Island

Quick Facts

  • Current Prices:$119,000 to $269,000
  • Closed Prices:$110,000 to $380,000
  • Median Sale Price:$190,000
  • Average $ per sq ft:$218
  • Association Fee Ranges:$0 to $440.36,$0 to $748/mo
(based on data from the last 12 months)
  • Type:Attached Home (Condo, Townhouse, Loft, etc.)
  • Age:1971 to 1980
  • Sq. Ft.:555 to 2,603Sq. Ft.
  • Bedrooms:0 to 3Bedrooms
  • Bathrooms:1 to 3Bathrooms


This community has numerous amenities available for residents to enjoy. Community members and their guests can make use of the beautiful tennis courts.


Looking to buy a new home? The community of Bay Island features a wonderful variety of designs to choose from. Most common in this neighborhood are attached homes, which usually have monthly homeowner association fees ranging from $1 to $748. Property taxes for the year range from as low as $799 to as high as $4,454.


Filter by:
3 Schools

Disclaimer: School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics and are subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.


Submit a review for Bay Island

Have something to say about this neighborhood? Tell the world!
Neighborhood Resident?

All reviews are subject to review prior to publication. Review guidelines.